« Yolanda King, 1955-2007 | Main | religion and the body politic »

Media Relations: copyright eternal, or, mark helprin either loses his mind or gets provocative

May 21, 2007

Media Relations: copyright eternal, or, mark helprin either loses his mind or gets provocative/ May 21, 2007

It's a stunningly badly argued piece; if it weren't for its headline, it would be unclear precisely what he's arguing for.

In general, he seems to be arguing that intellectual property rights -- including, probably, copyrights, patents and trademarks -- should all be protected in the same way that real property rights are. To be sure, he sets up a few straw men in his argument; for example, I can't recall that anyone has precisely argued that because something is trashy, it should automatically lose its legal protections, but he defends that side premise as though someone has done so.

He also draws parallels between real and intellectual property, stating that you're allowed to keep real property more or less intact (taxes aside), while intellectual property rights lapse after set amounts of time. I confess, while I think there's something wrong with that argument, I'm not entirely sure what it is or how to express it....


Posted by iain at May 21, 2007 01:20 PM

 

 

 

 

 

 

Recent posts

religion and the body politic

Media Relations: copyright eternal, or, mark helprin either loses his mind or gets provocative

Yolanda King, 1955-2007

media relations: no football wives this coming TV season

men vs women, youth vs age

underestimation and civility

chicago's police vs chicago

department of justice: systematic attempts to violate voter rights alleged

media relations: casino ... barbarella?

spaceport america

"and then a miracle occurred": emi offering unprotected music

chicago normal

sudan

conditions at walter reed

restoring the constitution act

another ex athlete comes out

secret detentions a-ok with the us government

a proposal for public health

media relations: scissors with malice?

love and marriage and murder and life sentences...

what would brian boitano do?

gay marriage in massachusetts to end in 2008, barring miracles

a surprising cautionary tale

moral coherence, or, why defense of gays matters

aclu vs cipa